Tag: bbc sherlock

Uncategorized

Do you think there is any chance Mary is faking the pregnancy? Sherlock wasn’t exactly on top of his game in S3 – making wrong deductions time and again. (Appledore vaults being the most obvious.) But what if Mary is playing at pregnancy, just as she played at normalcy? It could be the least long-term emotionally damaging for John. Yet, I do feel bad for Mary. She deserves someone who loves and marries her without being tricked. Maybe it could have been John, but she never gave him the chance.

No Comments

Follow-up to earlier ask: All the signs Sherlock deduces about Mary being pregnant in TSoT…

Read More
Uncategorized

The thing I don’t understand is, why the baby/pregnancy? To give Mary a motive for going after CAM, maybe, but isn’t putting John in a bonfire enough? And her pregnancy immediately makes her vulnerable, so they can ignore her background and make her a victim. But then why go through the trouble of making us feel conflicted about her with a half-baked redemption if we’re supposed to ultimately sympathize with her? Do you have any speculations about the purpose of the baby/pregnancy?

No Comments

I have many speculations, but they don’t really boil down in a useful fashion. Maybe…

Read More

« Previous Page — Next Page »

More to Check Out

Food

Old-Fashioned Bread

My Original Writing Writing

Promptober 2025 Day 28 & 31: Stairs to Nowhere and Guttering Candles

My Fanfic Writing

Promptober 2025 Day 26: An Extra Shadow

Fandom My Fanfic My Original Writing SCP Chicago Spirit Writing

Promptober 2025 Day 25: Footsteps in the Dark

Icon for Dreamwidth   Icon for Pillowfort   Icon for Mastodon   Icon for Archive of Our Own   Icon for RSS

Copyright prettyarbitrary © All rights reserved | Blogus by Themeansar.